Is it better to get a male or female horse?

Table of Contents

Ultimately, whether it’s better to get a male or female horse depends entirely on the individual’s needs, experience, and the intended use of the animal; however, generally, gelded males (geldings) are often considered more suitable for novice owners due to their typically calmer and more predictable temperaments.

Introduction: The Equine Gender Divide

Choosing a horse is a significant decision, and one of the first considerations is often gender. While personality and training play a far greater role than sex alone, understanding the inherent differences between male and female horses, as well as altered males, can help you make an informed choice that aligns with your riding goals and lifestyle. The question “Is it better to get a male or female horse?” is complex and nuanced. This article will explore the pros and cons of each to help you navigate this decision.

Mares: The Matriarchs of the Herd

Mares are adult female horses, prized for their intelligence and potential for breeding. They can be excellent riding partners, but understanding their hormonal cycles is key.

Advantages:
- Often have a strong work ethic.
- Can develop deep bonds with their owners.
- Potential for breeding high-quality foals.
Disadvantages:
- Can exhibit mood swings and irritability during their estrous cycle (heat).
- May be more prone to certain reproductive health issues.
- Some mares can be overly sensitive or “mare-ish” regardless of their cycle.

Geldings: The Reliable Companions

Geldings are male horses that have been castrated. This procedure significantly reduces testosterone levels, resulting in a calmer and more predictable temperament.

Advantages:
- Generally more even-tempered and easier to handle than stallions or mares in heat.
- Less prone to aggression or territorial behavior.
- Suitable for a wide range of disciplines and riders, including beginners.
Disadvantages:
- Cannot be used for breeding.
- Some geldings may lack the “spark” or ambition of stallions or mares.
- Early gelding can sometimes impact skeletal development, although this is often minimal.

Stallions: The Majestic Rulers (Handle with Care)

Stallions are intact adult male horses. They possess the highest levels of testosterone and are primarily used for breeding. Is it better to get a male or female horse? For the average rider, the answer is almost always “no” to stallions.

Advantages:
- Possess significant physical strength and presence.
- Can be highly intelligent and responsive to training in the right hands.
- Essential for breeding programs to improve bloodlines.
Disadvantages:
- Require experienced handlers and specialized management due to their strong instincts and potential for aggression.
- More challenging to train and manage than geldings or mares.
- Not suitable for novice or intermediate riders.

Temperament: Nature vs. Nurture

While gender plays a role, temperament is ultimately influenced by a horse’s genetics, upbringing, training, and handling. A well-trained and handled mare can be just as calm as a gelding, and a poorly trained gelding can be just as challenging as a stallion.

Conformation and Discipline

Consider the horse’s conformation (physical structure) in relation to your chosen discipline. Some disciplines may favor certain body types, which can sometimes be associated with gender. However, conformation should always be prioritized over gender.

Budget Considerations

The price of a horse can vary significantly depending on breed, age, training, and gender. Generally, stallions command the highest prices (especially those with proven bloodlines), followed by mares (especially those with proven breeding records), and then geldings. However, this is a generalization, and individual horses will vary.

Considerations for First-Time Horse Owners

For first-time horse owners, a gelding is often the most recommended choice. Their calmer temperament and ease of handling make them more forgiving of rider errors, allowing new owners to gain confidence and experience. While finding a mare is possible for the first time owner, proper guidance and evaluation from a professional is critical. The question is it better to get a male or female horse? can be answered for beginners most appropriately by looking into a gelding first.

Table: Comparing Genders

Feature	Mare	Gelding	Stallion
——————-	————————–	—————————	—————————–
Temperament	Variable, affected by heat	Generally calm and stable	Potentially aggressive, high-spirited
Training	Can be excellent	Typically easier to train	Requires experienced handler
Breeding Potential	Yes	No	Yes
Handling	Can be challenging during heat	Usually straightforward	Requires specialized handling
Cost	Moderate to High	Moderate	High

Seek Expert Advice

Before making a final decision, consult with experienced horse professionals, such as trainers, veterinarians, and breeders. They can assess your needs, evaluate individual horses, and provide valuable guidance.

FAQs

What is “mare-ish” behavior and how can I manage it?

“Mare-ish” behavior refers to mood swings and irritability exhibited by some mares, particularly during their estrous cycle. It can manifest as sensitivity, resistance to training, or aggression towards other horses. Management strategies include tracking her cycles, providing consistent training, and consulting with a veterinarian about potential supplements or medications to regulate hormonal imbalances. Consistent training is paramount to minimize the impact of these mood swings.

Are geldings always calmer than mares?

No, geldings are not always inherently calmer than mares. While castration reduces testosterone and typically leads to a more even temperament, individual personalities vary. A well-trained and well-handled mare can be just as calm and reliable as a gelding.

Can a mare still be ridden while pregnant?

Yes, mares can be ridden during the early stages of pregnancy. However, the intensity and duration of exercise should be gradually reduced as the pregnancy progresses. Consult with a veterinarian to determine a safe exercise plan for your pregnant mare.

What are the risks of owning a stallion?

Owning a stallion comes with significant risks, including potential for aggression, territorial behavior, and difficulty in handling. Stallions require experienced handlers and specialized management to ensure the safety of both the horse and the people around them. They are also prone to escaping their enclosures to breed. Responsible and experienced ownership is crucial.

Does gender affect a horse’s performance in specific disciplines?

While some disciplines may have historical preferences for certain genders, gender plays a less significant role than conformation, training, and athleticism. Excellent horses of both genders excel in various disciplines. Conformation should be your focus, rather than the question of “Is it better to get a male or female horse?“

What is the best age to geld a colt?

The optimal age to geld a colt varies, but it is commonly done between 6 months and 2 years of age. Consult with a veterinarian to determine the best timing for your individual horse, considering factors such as breed and physical development.

How can I tell if a horse is “mare-ish” before buying it?

Observing the mare’s behavior during different times of the month can provide clues about her temperament. Ask the seller about her history and any known behavioral issues. A pre-purchase veterinary exam can also identify potential hormonal imbalances.

Are there any health conditions that are more common in mares or geldings?

Mares are prone to reproductive health issues such as uterine infections or tumors. Geldings can be at slightly higher risk for certain musculoskeletal problems due to delayed closure of growth plates if gelded very young. However, both genders can experience a wide range of health conditions.

Can I turn a stallion out with other horses?

Turning a stallion out with other horses, especially mares, is generally not recommended unless he is a particularly docile individual and the environment is very secure. The presence of mares can trigger aggressive behavior and lead to injuries.

Does breed influence the temperament more than gender?

Yes, breed significantly influences temperament. Some breeds are known for being calmer and more docile, while others are more spirited and energetic. Consider breed characteristics when choosing a horse, in addition to gender. It’s not enough to wonder, “Is it better to get a male or female horse?” you should also be wondering, “What breed is the best horse?”

How can I build a strong bond with a mare?

Building a strong bond with a mare requires consistent training, positive reinforcement, and understanding her individual personality. Spend time grooming, handling, and working with her, and be patient and understanding during her hormonal fluctuations. Clear communication and consistency are key.

Are there specific training techniques that work better for mares or geldings?

While there is no one-size-fits-all approach, some trainers find that mares respond well to gentle and patient training methods, while geldings may be more tolerant of stricter discipline. However, individual personality should always be the primary consideration when choosing training techniques.