Is Frontline Plus as Good as NexGard? A Comparative Analysis
Is Frontline Plus as good as NexGard? The answer is complex: While both protect against fleas, NexGard offers broader protection and a different administration method, making it potentially superior for many pet owners, especially those concerned about ticks. This article dives deep into a detailed comparison.
Introduction: Understanding Flea and Tick Prevention
Protecting our beloved pets from fleas and ticks is a fundamental aspect of responsible pet ownership. These parasites can cause a range of issues, from mild skin irritation to serious diseases like Lyme disease and ehrlichiosis. Fortunately, numerous preventative products are available on the market, with Frontline Plus and NexGard being two of the most popular choices. However, choosing between them requires a thorough understanding of their differences and similarities.
Frontline Plus: The Topical Treatment
Frontline Plus is a topical medication, meaning it is applied directly to the pet’s skin, usually between the shoulder blades. It works by killing fleas and ticks through contact.
- Active Ingredients: Fipronil and (S)-methoprene
- Application: Topical (applied to the skin)
- Target Parasites: Fleas, ticks, chewing lice
- Frequency: Monthly application
NexGard: The Oral Chew
NexGard, on the other hand, is an oral medication presented as a palatable chew. It enters the pet’s bloodstream, and when fleas and ticks bite, they ingest the medication and are killed.
- Active Ingredient: Afoxolaner
- Application: Oral (chewable tablet)
- Target Parasites: Fleas, ticks (including the Lone Star tick), mange mites, and ear mites (select species)
- Frequency: Monthly administration
Comparing Effectiveness: Fleas and Ticks
The efficacy of both products is a critical factor when deciding which to use.
- Fleas: Both Frontline Plus and NexGard are highly effective at killing fleas. However, NexGard starts killing fleas faster – often within hours – compared to Frontline Plus, which may take up to 24 hours.
- Ticks: NexGard generally provides broader protection against a wider range of tick species compared to Frontline Plus. NexGard also provides more consistent and effective protection against the Lone Star tick, which is becoming increasingly prevalent.
- Other Parasites: NexGard offers the added benefit of treating and controlling certain types of mange mites and ear mites, which Frontline Plus does not.
Administration: Topical vs. Oral
The method of administration is a significant consideration for many pet owners.
- Frontline Plus (Topical): Some pet owners find the topical application easy, but it can be messy and requires waiting for the application site to dry completely. There’s also a risk of children or other pets coming into contact with the wet application site.
- NexGard (Oral): Most dogs readily accept NexGard chews, making administration simpler for many owners. There’s no mess and no waiting period, and it eliminates the risk of wash-off due to bathing or swimming.
Safety Considerations: Potential Side Effects
Both Frontline Plus and NexGard are generally considered safe for dogs and cats when used according to label instructions. However, potential side effects exist.
| Product | Potential Side Effects |
|---|---|
| :————- | :—————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————— |
| Frontline Plus | Temporary irritation at the application site, skin reactions. In rare cases: vomiting, diarrhea, or neurological signs. |
| NexGard | Vomiting, diarrhea, lethargy, decreased appetite, and skin irritations have been reported. In rare cases, NexGard has been associated with neurological signs, including seizures, particularly in dogs with a history of seizures. |
It’s crucial to consult with your veterinarian about your pet’s specific health history and any potential risks before starting any new medication.
Cost Comparison: Which is More Affordable?
The cost of Frontline Plus and NexGard can vary depending on the retailer, location, and size of your pet. Generally, NexGard tends to be slightly more expensive than Frontline Plus per dose. However, considering NexGard’s broader spectrum of protection and ease of administration, many owners find the extra cost worthwhile. It is always best to shop around and compare prices.
Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider
Ultimately, deciding if Frontline Plus is as good as NexGard? depends on your individual pet’s needs and circumstances. Consider the following factors:
- Tick Prevalence in Your Area: If you live in an area with a high tick population, particularly the Lone Star tick, NexGard might be a better choice due to its broader and more effective tick protection.
- Your Pet’s Temperament: If your pet is difficult to medicate topically, NexGard’s chewable format may be a more convenient option.
- Your Pet’s Health History: Discuss your pet’s medical history with your veterinarian, especially if they have a history of seizures or other neurological issues, as NexGard has been linked to rare occurrences of seizures in some dogs.
- Budget: Factor in the cost of both products when making your decision.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is Frontline Plus effective against all types of ticks?
Frontline Plus is effective against several common tick species, including brown dog ticks, American dog ticks, and deer ticks (black-legged ticks). However, it may not be as effective against the Lone Star tick as some other products, including NexGard.
How quickly does NexGard start killing fleas?
NexGard is known for its rapid action against fleas. It typically starts killing fleas within just a few hours of administration, often within 4 hours, offering quicker relief for your pet.
Can I use Frontline Plus and NexGard together?
It is generally not recommended to use Frontline Plus and NexGard together. Using both products simultaneously could increase the risk of adverse reactions due to the overlapping effects of the medications. Always consult with your veterinarian before combining any medications.
Is NexGard safe for all dogs?
While NexGard is generally safe, it’s essential to discuss your dog’s health history with your veterinarian before starting NexGard. Dogs with a history of seizures should be carefully evaluated, as NexGard has been associated with rare cases of seizures.
Can I bathe my dog after applying Frontline Plus?
Yes, but it is important to wait at least 24 hours after applying Frontline Plus before bathing your dog. Bathing too soon after application may reduce the effectiveness of the product.
Does Frontline Plus protect against heartworm?
Frontline Plus does not protect against heartworm. Heartworm prevention requires a separate medication. Consult your veterinarian about appropriate heartworm prevention options for your pet.
How often should I apply Frontline Plus or administer NexGard?
Both Frontline Plus and NexGard are typically administered monthly to provide continuous protection against fleas and ticks. Follow the label instructions and your veterinarian’s recommendations.
What happens if I miss a dose of Frontline Plus or NexGard?
If you miss a dose, administer it as soon as you remember. If it is almost time for the next dose, skip the missed dose and continue with the regular schedule. Avoid doubling the dose to catch up.
Is NexGard safe for pregnant or lactating dogs?
The safety of NexGard in pregnant or lactating dogs has not been fully established. Consult with your veterinarian before using NexGard on pregnant or lactating animals.
Can I use Frontline Plus on my cat?
Frontline Plus for dogs and Frontline Plus for cats are different formulations. Always use the product specifically designed for the species of your pet. Using the dog formulation on a cat can be harmful.
What are the signs of a flea or tick infestation in my pet?
Common signs include excessive scratching, biting, or licking; visible fleas or ticks in the fur; flea dirt (small black specks) in the fur; and skin irritation or hair loss.
Where can I purchase Frontline Plus and NexGard?
You can purchase Frontline Plus and NexGard from veterinary clinics, pet stores, and online retailers. NexGard typically requires a prescription from your veterinarian.