Does owning a pitbull increase homeowners insurance?

Table of Contents

Yes, often owning a pitbull can significantly increase your homeowners insurance premiums or even make it difficult to obtain coverage. This is because insurance companies perceive certain dog breeds, including pitbulls, as high-risk due to their perceived potential for causing serious injuries.

The Impact of Breed-Specific Legislation on Homeowners Insurance

The relationship between dog breeds and homeowners insurance is complex, intertwined with local regulations and insurance company policies. Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL), laws that restrict or ban certain dog breeds, plays a significant role. These laws often target breeds like pitbulls, Rottweilers, and Doberman Pinschers. Even in areas without BSL, insurance companies can implement their own breed restrictions. The reason behind this stems from liability concerns. Insurance companies assess risk based on historical data and believe that certain breeds are statistically more likely to bite or cause injuries, leading to claims.

Why are Pitbulls Considered High-Risk by Insurance Companies?

The perception of pitbulls as high-risk dogs isn’t arbitrary. It’s rooted in a combination of factors, including:

Bite Statistics: While bite statistics can be debated and influenced by reporting biases, some studies show pitbulls involved in a disproportionate number of serious bite incidents.
Physical Strength: Pitbulls possess powerful jaws and musculature, making their bites potentially more damaging.
Media Portrayal: Negative media coverage of pitbull attacks contributes to public perception and influences insurance companies.
Breeding History: Pitbulls were originally bred for bull-baiting and dogfighting, activities that emphasized aggression.

It’s important to note that not all pitbulls are aggressive, and a dog’s temperament is influenced by training, socialization, and responsible ownership. However, the historical data and potential for serious injury lead many insurers to categorize them as high-risk.

How Homeowners Insurance Policies Address Dog Breeds

Homeowners insurance policies provide liability coverage that protects homeowners from financial losses if their dog bites or injures someone. Insurance companies address dog breed risk in several ways:

Breed Restrictions: Some policies explicitly exclude coverage for certain breeds, meaning they won’t pay out claims if a dog of that breed causes an injury.
Increased Premiums: Homeowners with restricted breeds may be charged higher premiums to offset the perceived risk.
Cancellation or Non-Renewal: Existing policies may be canceled or not renewed if the homeowner acquires a dog of a restricted breed.
Liability Waivers: Some insurers may require homeowners with restricted breeds to sign a waiver accepting full responsibility for any injuries caused by their dog.

Alternatives for Homeowners with Pitbulls

If you own a pitbull and are struggling to find homeowners insurance, several alternatives exist:

Shop Around: Contact multiple insurance companies to compare policies and find one that doesn’t have breed restrictions. Smaller, local insurers may be more flexible.
Canine Good Citizen Certification: Obtaining a Canine Good Citizen (CGC) certification for your pitbull can demonstrate that your dog is well-trained and well-behaved. Some insurers offer discounts for CGC-certified dogs.
Umbrella Policy: Consider purchasing an umbrella liability policy, which provides additional coverage beyond your homeowners insurance. This can help protect you financially in case of a serious dog bite incident.
Specialty Dog Liability Insurance: There are insurance companies that specialize in providing coverage for dog breeds that are typically excluded from standard homeowners policies. These policies may be more expensive but offer essential protection.
Modify your Home: Installing a fence or other containment system can reduce the risk of your dog escaping and injuring someone. Some insurers may offer discounts for these safety measures.

Common Mistakes When Insuring a Pitbull

Navigating the insurance landscape with a pitbull can be challenging. Avoid these common mistakes:

Misrepresenting Your Dog’s Breed: Lying about your dog’s breed is considered insurance fraud and can result in policy cancellation and denial of claims.
Neglecting Training and Socialization: Proper training and socialization are crucial for any dog, but especially for pitbulls. A well-behaved dog is less likely to bite.
Failing to Disclose: Failing to disclose your dog’s breed to your insurance company can result in denial of coverage if an incident occurs.
Ignoring Local Regulations: Be aware of local BSL laws and ensure you are in compliance.

Breed	Typical Homeowners Insurance Impact
———–	———–
Pitbull	Higher premiums, potential exclusion
Rottweiler	Higher premiums, potential exclusion
German Shepherd	Higher premiums, potential exclusion
Doberman Pinscher	Higher premiums, potential exclusion
Labrador Retriever	Generally no impact
Golden Retriever	Generally no impact

The Importance of Responsible Pitbull Ownership

Ultimately, responsible pitbull ownership is the best way to mitigate risk and improve your chances of obtaining homeowners insurance. This includes:

Thorough Training: Invest in obedience training and socialization classes.
Secure Containment: Ensure your dog is safely contained within your property.
Leash Laws: Always keep your dog on a leash when in public.
Early Socialization: Expose your dog to a variety of people, animals, and environments from a young age.
Responsible Breeding: If you are considering breeding pitbulls, prioritize temperament and health.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why do insurance companies discriminate against certain dog breeds?

Insurance companies use actuarial data to assess risk. They believe that certain breeds, like pitbulls, statistically pose a higher risk of causing serious injuries, leading to costly claims. While this is controversial and doesn’t account for individual dog temperament, it’s the basis for their breed-specific policies.

If my pitbull has never bitten anyone, will my insurance still be affected?

Yes, even if your pitbull has a spotless record, insurance companies may still charge higher premiums or deny coverage based on the breed’s perceived risk. The risk assessment is based on breed characteristics and statistics, not individual dog behavior.

What is a Canine Good Citizen (CGC) certification, and how can it help?

The Canine Good Citizen program is a certification that demonstrates a dog’s good manners and obedience. Earning a CGC certification can show your insurance company that your pitbull is well-trained and poses a lower risk, potentially leading to discounts or better coverage options.

Can I get away with not disclosing my pitbull to my insurance company?

No. Misrepresenting your dog’s breed is insurance fraud and can have serious consequences. If your dog bites someone and you haven’t disclosed the breed, your claim could be denied, and your policy could be canceled.

What happens if my insurance company cancels my policy because I own a pitbull?

If your policy is canceled, you’ll need to find a new insurance provider immediately. You may need to explore specialty dog liability insurance or consider an umbrella policy to protect yourself from potential liability.

Is it possible to appeal an insurance company’s decision to deny coverage based on breed?

Yes, you can appeal the decision by providing evidence of your dog’s good temperament, training, and responsible ownership. Submit your dog’s CGC certification, veterinarian records, and testimonials from neighbors or trainers. However, the insurance company is not obligated to reverse its decision.

Does renters insurance also have breed restrictions?

Yes, renters insurance policies can also have breed restrictions similar to homeowners insurance. If you own a pitbull, it’s essential to disclose the breed to your renters insurance provider to ensure you have adequate liability coverage.

What is an umbrella liability policy, and how does it relate to pitbull ownership?

An umbrella liability policy provides additional liability coverage beyond your homeowners or renters insurance. It can protect you financially if your dog bites someone and the damages exceed the limits of your primary insurance policy. This is especially helpful for pitbull owners.

Are there any states where insurance companies cannot discriminate based on dog breed?

Some states have laws that restrict or prohibit insurance companies from denying coverage or charging higher premiums based solely on a dog’s breed. Research the laws in your state to understand your rights.

What can I do if I can’t find any insurance that covers my pitbull?

If you’re unable to find any insurance coverage, consider implementing additional safety measures, such as installing a secure fence, using a muzzle in public, and enrolling in advanced obedience training. Document these efforts to demonstrate your commitment to responsible ownership.

How does the size of my dog relate to insurance premiums?

While breed is the primary factor, the size of your dog can also influence insurance premiums. Larger dogs, regardless of breed, may be perceived as posing a greater risk of causing serious injuries, potentially leading to higher premiums.

Should I get my pitbull certified as a service animal or emotional support animal to get insurance?

No. Falsely claiming your dog is a service animal or emotional support animal is illegal and unethical. Moreover, insurance companies are unlikely to be swayed by such designations if the dog’s breed is considered high-risk. Be honest and transparent about your dog’s breed and training.