Should I use a doe or buck call during rut?

Table of Contents

During the rut, choosing between a doe and a buck call can significantly impact your hunting success. Deciding which call to use depends heavily on the specific stage of the rut and the behavior you’re trying to elicit, but generally, doe calls are more versatile and effective throughout the rut, especially for attracting bucks searching for receptive does.

Understanding Deer Vocalizations and the Rut

The white-tailed deer rut is a period of intense breeding activity, characterized by increased movement, aggression, and vocal communication. Understanding the nuances of deer vocalizations is crucial for effective calling strategies. Bucks and does use a variety of calls, each conveying different messages and triggering specific responses. Successfully calling in a deer involves mimicking these sounds at the right time and in the right context. Should I use a doe or buck call during rut? The answer lies in understanding these vocalizations.

Doe Bleats: Soft, nasal sounds used by does to communicate with fawns or attract bucks. A general attractant throughout the rut.
Estrus Bleats: More urgent and pleading calls made by does nearing estrus (heat), signaling their readiness to breed. Highly effective in the peak rut.
Buck Grunts: Short, guttural sounds made by bucks, often used to assert dominance or challenge other bucks. More effective during pre-rut and post-rut.
Rattling: Antler-to-antler contact, simulating a buck fight, used to attract dominant bucks. Effective during pre-rut and sometimes during peak rut.
Snort-Wheeze: An aggressive vocalization used by bucks as a warning or challenge. Use sparingly and cautiously.

Benefits of Using Doe Calls

Doe calls are generally considered more versatile and less risky than buck calls during the rut. They appeal to a wider range of bucks, from young bucks looking for their first mate to mature bucks searching for receptive does.

Attracts a wider range of bucks: Doe calls can entice both young and mature bucks.
Lower risk of spooking deer: Less aggressive than buck calls, reducing the chance of alarming deer.
Effective throughout the rut: Useful from pre-rut to post-rut, especially during the peak.
Mimics natural communication: Replicates the sounds does use to attract bucks naturally.

Benefits of Using Buck Calls

Buck calls can be effective, but they require a more nuanced understanding of deer behavior and timing. Using them incorrectly can easily spook deer or attract unwanted attention from dominant bucks, leading to a confrontation you might not be prepared for.

Challenges dominant bucks: Can draw in aggressive bucks looking for a fight.
Asserts dominance: Signals the presence of another buck in the area.
Effective in pre-rut: When bucks are establishing dominance hierarchies.
Can intimidate younger bucks: Drives off competition for does.

When to Use Doe Calls

The optimal time to use doe calls is during the peak of the rut, when does are actively seeking mates and bucks are frantically searching for them. However, they can also be effective in the pre-rut and post-rut. Should I use a doe or buck call during rut?, this is a matter of timing.

Pre-Rut: Use soft bleats to pique the interest of bucks.
Peak Rut: Utilize estrus bleats to signal the presence of a receptive doe.
Post-Rut: Continue using soft bleats, as some does may still be receptive.

When to Use Buck Calls

Buck calls are most effective during the pre-rut, when bucks are establishing dominance and fighting for territory. Rattling can also be successful during this time. Use caution when using buck calls during the peak rut, as it can spook does or attract unwanted attention from dominant bucks.

Pre-Rut: Grunts and rattling to challenge other bucks.
Peak Rut: Use sparingly and only if you see a buck that is not responding to doe calls.
Post-Rut: Grunts can still be effective, as bucks continue to assert dominance.

Common Mistakes When Using Deer Calls

Avoiding common mistakes is crucial for successful deer calling. Overcalling, using the wrong call at the wrong time, and failing to consider wind direction can all sabotage your efforts.

Overcalling: Calling too frequently or too loudly can spook deer.
Using the wrong call: Using a buck call when does are nearby can scare them away.
Failing to consider wind direction: Deer have an excellent sense of smell, and calling into the wind can alert them to your presence.
Lack of realism: Inconsistent or unnatural sounds will easily be detected.

Choosing the Right Call

Selecting the right type of call is crucial for success. Many different types of doe and buck calls are available, from mouth calls to electronic calls. Experiment with different calls to find what works best in your area.

Mouth Calls: Require practice but offer a wide range of vocalizations.
Electronic Calls: Offer a variety of pre-recorded sounds, making them easy to use.
Rattling Antlers: Effective for simulating buck fights.

Integrating Calling into Your Hunting Strategy

Calling is just one component of a successful hunting strategy. Consider other factors such as stand placement, wind direction, and scent control. Integrating calling into a well-planned hunting strategy will significantly increase your chances of success.

Stand Placement: Position yourself in an area where deer are likely to travel.
Wind Direction: Always hunt with the wind in your face to prevent deer from smelling you.
Scent Control: Use scent-reducing products to minimize your scent signature.
Observation: Watch and listen to deer behavior to determine the best calling strategy.

Comparing Doe and Buck Calls

Here’s a table to help you quickly compare doe and buck calls:

Feature	Doe Calls	Buck Calls
—————-	—————————-	——————————-
Effectiveness	Versatile, generally effective	More situational, can be risky
Target Audience	Both young and mature bucks	Primarily mature bucks
Risk	Lower risk of spooking deer	Higher risk of spooking deer
Best Time	Throughout the rut	Pre-rut, sometimes peak rut

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is it better to use a doe bleat or estrus bleat during peak rut?

An estrus bleat is generally more effective during the peak rut because it mimics the sound of a doe that is ready to breed, which is what bucks are actively searching for during this time. A doe bleat is still useful as a general attractant, but the urgency of the estrus bleat can be more compelling.

Can I use a buck call if I see a small buck?

Using a buck call when you see a small buck is generally not recommended. Small bucks are less likely to respond aggressively to a challenge and may be intimidated and run away. It’s usually better to use a doe call to attract the buck’s attention without scaring it off.

How often should I use a deer call?

The frequency of calling depends on the situation. Start with a few soft calls and observe the deer’s reaction. If they show interest, you can call more frequently. If they seem spooked, reduce your calling. Overcalling can be counterproductive.

What is the best time of day to use deer calls?

The best time of day to use deer calls is during the early morning and late afternoon, when deer are most active. However, calling can be effective throughout the day, especially during the peak rut.

What should I do if a deer comes in but doesn’t offer a good shot?

If a deer comes in but doesn’t offer a good shot, remain calm and avoid making any sudden movements. Try to reposition yourself for a better shot, or wait for the deer to move into a more favorable position. If the deer spooks, avoid calling again in the immediate area.

Can electronic calls replace mouth calls?

Electronic calls offer convenience and pre-recorded sounds, but mouth calls provide greater control and realism. Both types of calls can be effective, but mastering a mouth call can give you an edge.

How important is scent control when using deer calls?

Scent control is extremely important when using deer calls. Deer have an excellent sense of smell, and they will quickly detect your presence if you are not careful. Use scent-reducing products and hunt with the wind in your face.

What is the purpose of rattling antlers?

Rattling antlers simulates a buck fight, attracting dominant bucks looking to assert their dominance. This technique is most effective during the pre-rut, when bucks are establishing dominance hierarchies.

Should I use a buck grunt call on a doe?

No, you should not use a buck grunt call on a doe. Buck grunt calls are intended for other bucks. Using a grunt call on a doe will likely confuse her and could even scare her away.

How do I know if I am overcalling?

You are likely overcalling if deer react negatively to your calls, such as becoming alert, nervous, or running away. Reduce your calling frequency and volume if you notice these behaviors.

What is the difference between a fawn bleat and a doe bleat?

A fawn bleat is a higher-pitched, more plaintive sound used by fawns to communicate with their mothers. A doe bleat is a lower-pitched, more nasal sound used by does to communicate with fawns or attract bucks. During the rut, focus on the doe bleat.

Should I use a deer call if it’s windy?

Using a deer call when it’s windy can be challenging because the wind can distort the sound and make it difficult for deer to hear. However, you can still use a call effectively by calling louder and more frequently. Also, consider the wind direction. Should I use a doe or buck call during rut? The answer often changes based on these conditions.